Key points
- Seoul appeals court upholds Kakao founder Kim Beom-su’s acquittal
- What prosecutors alleged in the fight for SM Entertainment
- Kakao shares fall as SM Entertainment rises
A Seoul appeals court has upheld the acquittal of Kakao founder Kim Beom-su (김범수) on charges of manipulating SM Entertainment shares during the 2023 battle with HYBE (하이브) for control of the K-pop company.
The Seoul High Court (서울고법) also upheld the acquittal of Bae Jae-hyun (배재현), Kakao’s former head of investment. Both men were found not guilty at their first trial in October 2025.
The court said prosecutors’ evidence did not prove that the defendants intended to manipulate or artificially stabilize SM’s share price, or that they conspired to do so. The ruling came at 10:20 a.m. Seoul time on Friday, Nov. 20, or 8:20 p.m. ET on Thursday, Cox News (콕스뉴스) reported.
Prosecutors said Kakao spent 240 billion won to block HYBE's bid
The case goes back to February 2023, when HYBE, the company behind BTS, launched a tender offer for SM shares at 120,000 won ($89.72 USD) each. For those that don't know, a tender offer is a public offer to buy shares from any shareholder at a fixed price for a set period. If the stock trades above that price on the market, shareholders can get more by selling there instead, which makes the offer harder to complete.
Prosecutors said Kakao spent about 240 billion won ($179 million USD) buying SM shares in 553 trades to keep the price above HYBE's 120,000 won offer. HYBE dropped its takeover attempt in March 2023, and Kakao took control of SM.
In the appeal, prosecutors asked for 15 years in prison for Kim and 12 years for Bae. Kim had been arrested in July 2024 and released on bail that October.
The court said ordinary market purchases to gather support during a takeover contest can be a common defense. "Buying shares on the market in the usual way to gather friendly stakes during a tender offer or a hostile takeover is a common way to defend control of a company," the court said, according to Hankyung (한국경제). It added that almost any trade can move a price, and that punishing every purchase for that reason alone would be unfair.
Kim says the ruling ends three years of uncertainty for Kakao
Kim, who now heads Kakao's Future Initiative Center, stepped down as chair of the company's group control tower, the CA Council, in March 2025. He thanked the court in a statement after the ruling.
"Today's ruling is an important turning point that clears away the uncertainty that has surrounded Kakao for the past three years," Kim said. "Now that AI is changing whole industries and everyday life, Kakao has to open a new path to growth, too."
The case isn't necessarily over. Prosecutors can still appeal to Korea's Supreme Court. Under Korean criminal procedure, they have seven days from the ruling to file.
Kakao shares slip as the Kospi falls 4%
Kakao shares were little changed when the verdict came out. By 11:16 a.m. in Seoul, they were down 1.9% at 31,300 won ($23.40 USD), according to Naver Finance data. The Kospi was down 4.25% at the same time, as chip and AI stocks sold off across Asia.
SM Entertainment shares were up 5.6% at 100,400 won ($75.07 USD).
The first acquittal got a much bigger reaction. On Oct. 21, 2025, Kakao closed up 6% at 62,300 won ($46.58 USD). The stock has lost about half its value since then, and it fell 7.49% on Aug. 21 when the company announced plans to split into Kakao AI and Kakao X.
Quotes from the court and from Kim are translated from Korean. Dollar figures, including those for the 2023 and 2025 prices, use the Nov. 20, 2026, exchange rate of 1,337.45 won per dollar for comparison.













